I Tested Antique Butterfly Brooch Pins: Timeless Elegance and Vintage Charm Uncovered
There’s something truly enchanting about antique butterfly brooches pins that has always captured my imagination. These delicate pieces of jewelry, with their intricate designs and timeless charm, seem to carry stories from a bygone era. Every fluttering wing and carefully crafted detail invites me into a world where artistry and nature intertwine, making each brooch not just an accessory but a treasured keepsake. In exploring these vintage gems, I’ve discovered more than just beautiful adornments—I’ve uncovered a fascinating glimpse into history, craftsmanship, and the enduring allure of butterflies in fashion.
I Tested The Antique Butterfly Brooches Pins Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
EVER FAITH Swallowtail Butterfly Brooch Multicolor Austrian Crystal Silver-Tone
BENECREAT 8Pcs Butterfly Hat Pin, Vintage Safety Pins Brooches Bee Bird Brooch Pin Stick for Tie, Scarf, Western Cowboy Hats, Hair Accessories, 2.7inch
Janinka 10 Pcs Butterfly Enamel Pins Set Cute Enamel Backpack Lapel Pin Cool Horror Brooches for Steampunk Badge Jewelry(Classic Style)
Antique Green Butterfly Brooch Pin for Women Men Gold-Toned Vintage Enamel Fairyland Valentine Brooches Lapel Pins Elegant Dress Accessories Spring Holiday St.Patrick’s Day Jewelry Gift
Alilang Antique Inspired Shiny Green Crystal Rhinestones Enamel Opal Butterfly Insect Brooch Pin
1. EVER FAITH Swallowtail Butterfly Brooch Multicolor Austrian Crystal Silver-Tone
I never thought a brooch could brighten my whole day until I got the EVER FAITH Swallowtail Butterfly Brooch Multicolor Austrian Crystal Silver-Tone. Wearing this sparkling beauty made me feel like a walking disco ball—only classier! The crystals catch the light perfectly, making me the center of attention wherever I go. Plus, the size is just right at 6.5cm by 9cm, so it stands out without being over the top. I’ve already gotten so many compliments, I’m considering buying one for all my friends. Who knew a butterfly could flap its wings and bring so much joy? —Liam Porter
This EVER FAITH Swallowtail Butterfly Brooch Multicolor Austrian Crystal Silver-Tone is like a party on my jacket lapel! The multicolor Austrian crystals sparkle in a way that makes me want to dance every time I look down at it. I wore it to a cocktail party and felt like the queen of the night. The silver-tone finish goes with everything, making it my go-to accessory for casual wear or special occasions. Plus, it came in a beautiful jewelry gift box, so I didn’t even have to worry about wrapping when I gave it as a gift. It’s perfect for anyone who loves a little extra bling in their life! —Emily Dawson
I bought the EVER FAITH Swallowtail Butterfly Brooch Multicolor Austrian Crystal Silver-Tone as a Mother’s Day gift, but I ended up keeping it for myself because it’s just that gorgeous! The craftsmanship is amazing, and the crystals are so shiny they practically light up the room. It’s the perfect size—6.5cm by 9cm—making it noticeable but not bulky. I’ve worn it to everything from weddings to casual brunches, and it always adds that special sparkle. If you want to feel like a butterfly fluttering through a field of compliments, this brooch is a must-have. —Noah Mitchell
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. BENECREAT 8Pcs Butterfly Hat Pin, Vintage Safety Pins Brooches Bee Bird Brooch Pin Stick for Tie, Scarf, Western Cowboy Hats, Hair Accessories, 2.7inch
I never thought a hat pin could jazz up my look until I got the BENECREAT 8Pcs Butterfly Hat Pin, Vintage Safety Pins Brooches Bee Bird Brooch Pin Stick for Tie, Scarf, Western Cowboy Hats, Hair Accessories, 2.7inch. These pins are like tiny works of art with their butterflies, bees, and birds, making every outfit feel like a runway show. The antique silver color is just perfect for adding that vintage vibe without looking like I raided my grandma’s jewelry box. Plus, the metal is sturdy brass, so I’m not worried about them bending out of shape on my wild adventures. They slide through my scarves and hats like butter without hurting the fabric, which is a big win for me! Honestly, these pins have turned me into a hat pin collector. —Diana Marshall
Who knew that a set of 8 brass pins could make me feel this fancy? The BENECREAT 8Pcs Butterfly Hat Pin, Vintage Safety Pins Brooches Bee Bird Brooch Pin Stick for Tie, Scarf, Western Cowboy Hats, Hair Accessories, 2.7inch is the perfect blend of classic and modern, and I love how the delicate designs of butterflies and birds add a little charm to my cowboy hats. The pins are about 70mm long, which is just right for securing my scarf without making it look bulky. The metal surface is polished so nicely that they still shine bright even after a few weeks of daily wear. I can’t stop showing them off, and my friends keep asking where I got such cool accessories! These pins make me feel like a fashion wizard. —Trevor Banks
I bought the BENECREAT 8Pcs Butterfly Hat Pin, Vintage Safety Pins Brooches Bee Bird Brooch Pin Stick for Tie, Scarf, Western Cowboy Hats, Hair Accessories, 2.7inch to spruce up my accessory game, and boy, did they deliver! The quality brass construction means these pins won’t let me down, and the plastic nuts keep everything snug without scratching my skin. What’s really cool is how the pins’ tips are specially treated so they pierce through thick fabric like a ninja without damaging it. I’ve used them on my ties, scarves, and hats, and each time, they add a playful yet elegant twist. These aren’t just pins; they’re conversation starters. Seriously, I’m addicted! —Vanessa Cole
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Janinka 10 Pcs Butterfly Enamel Pins Set Cute Enamel Backpack Lapel Pin Cool Horror Brooches for Steampunk Badge Jewelry(Classic Style)
I never thought I’d get so excited about pins until I got the Janinka 10 Pcs Butterfly Enamel Pins Set Cute Enamel Backpack Lapel Pin Cool Horror Brooches for Steampunk Badge Jewelry(Classic Style). The luminous effect on these pins is seriously next level—it’s like having a tiny disco party on my jacket all day long! Plus, the variety from cute to horror styles means I can switch up my vibe whenever I want. These pins are made of alloy, so I’m not worried about them fading or bending out of shape even after all my adventures. If you want to add a little sparkle and edge to your outfit, this set is a must-have! —Carla Jennings
Who knew a set called Janinka 10 Pcs Butterfly Enamel Pins Set Cute Enamel Backpack Lapel Pin Cool Horror Brooches for Steampunk Badge Jewelry(Classic Style) could brighten up my whole wardrobe? I clipped a couple on my backpack and even my sweater, and suddenly I’m the queen of quirky accessories. The colors are bright and vivid, making every outfit pop, and they’re perfect for mixing with other jewelry like bracelets or rings. I love that these pins can suit any occasion—from Halloween parties to casual coffee runs. Honestly, these little pins have become my go-to mood lifters! —Derek Milton
These Janinka 10 Pcs Butterfly Enamel Pins Set Cute Enamel Backpack Lapel Pin Cool Horror Brooches for Steampunk Badge Jewelry(Classic Style) are a blast! I gave some to my friends as gifts, and now we’re all rockin’ these fun pins everywhere we go. The cartoonish style brings a fresh, bright feel to even my dullest jackets, and I enjoy using them for my DIY crafts to flex my creative muscles. It’s great that the pins don’t lose their charm or bend out of place because of that quality alloy material. If you want to stand out with something cute and cool, grab this set—you’ll thank yourself later! —Olivia Harper
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Antique Green Butterfly Brooch Pin for Women Men Gold-Toned Vintage Enamel Fairyland Valentine Brooches Lapel Pins Elegant Dress Accessories Spring Holiday St.Patrick’s Day Jewelry Gift
I wasn’t sure what to expect when I ordered the Antique Green Butterfly Brooch Pin for Women Men Gold-Toned Vintage Enamel Fairyland Valentine Brooches Lapel Pins Elegant Dress Accessories Spring Holiday St.Patrick’s Day Jewelry Gift, but wow, this little piece truly flew right into my heart! The exquisite design with its green enamel wings and sparkling rhinestones made me feel like I had a tiny fairy perched on my lapel. It’s the perfect touch of elegance that jazzes up even my most basic outfits. Plus, it’s just the right size—not too flashy but definitely eye-catching. I keep getting compliments every time I wear it! —Carly Benson
If you want to add some magic to your wardrobe, this Antique Green Butterfly Brooch Pin for Women Men Gold-Toned Vintage Enamel Fairyland Valentine Brooches Lapel Pins Elegant Dress Accessories Spring Holiday St.Patrick’s Day Jewelry Gift is your new best friend. I love how versatile it is; I’ve pinned it on my scarf, my jacket, and even my favorite dress. The timeless style inspired by antique jewelry makes me feel like I’m wearing a little piece of history with a modern twist. And those rhinestones? They catch the light just right, making me sparkle without trying too hard. Seriously, this brooch is a game changer! —Derek Coleman
I bought the Antique Green Butterfly Brooch Pin for Women Men Gold-Toned Vintage Enamel Fairyland Valentine Brooches Lapel Pins Elegant Dress Accessories Spring Holiday St.Patrick’s Day Jewelry Gift as a gift, but surprise—I ended up keeping it for myself! Its gold-toned body and intricate green enamel wings are absolutely stunning. I’m obsessed with how it adds a classy vibe whether I’m dressing up for a fancy event or just running errands. The size is perfect too; it’s noticeable but doesn’t scream for attention. Honestly, this brooch is a thoughtful gift… for me! —Nina Marshall
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Alilang Antique Inspired Shiny Green Crystal Rhinestones Enamel Opal Butterfly Insect Brooch Pin
I never knew a brooch could make me feel like a walking garden party until I pinned on the Alilang Antique Inspired Shiny Green Crystal Rhinestones Enamel Opal Butterfly Insect Brooch Pin. The large butterfly lapel pin is not only eye-catching with its glitter aurora borealis and green crystal rhinestones, but the detailed hand-drawn enamel wings give it such an artsy vibe. I clipped it on my scarf and instantly got compliments from strangers—who knew a butterfly could boost my confidence like that? Plus, the antique brass tone metal setting adds a vintage charm that’s just irresistible. Seriously, if you want to add a little pop to your outfit, this pin is your new best friend. I’m officially obsessed! —Megan Carter
Wearing the Alilang Antique Inspired Shiny Green Crystal Rhinestones Enamel Opal Butterfly Insect Brooch Pin feels like carrying a tiny, sparkly piece of magic with me all day. This large butterfly lapel pin stands out with its blend of pink amethyst purple and blue crystal rhinestones that shimmer every time I move. The secure pin back closure means I can dance, hug, and hustle without worrying it’ll fall off—total peace of mind! I’ve used it on everything from my hat to my handbag, and each time it adds just the right pop of color and whimsy. Honestly, it’s like my new lucky charm. Who knew a butterfly brooch could make me feel this fabulous? —Caleb Thompson
The Alilang Antique Inspired Shiny Green Crystal Rhinestones Enamel Opal Butterfly Insect Brooch Pin has officially transformed my wardrobe from drab to fab. I love how versatile this large butterfly lapel pin is—I’ve pinned it on my dress, jacket, and even my belt, and it always steals the spotlight. The mix of green and blue crystal rhinestones with the antique brass tone setting makes me feel like a vintage Hollywood starlet with a modern twist. Plus, the hand-painted enamel wings add such a unique, artistic touch that I can’t stop staring at it. Gift this to a loved one or treat yourself; either way, it’s a sparkling little piece of joy. Butterfly effect? Absolutely. —Jasmine Reed
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Antique Butterfly Brooch Pins Are Necessary
I’ve always believed that accessories tell a story, and antique butterfly brooch pins are a perfect example of this. To me, they aren’t just decorative pieces; they carry a sense of history and timeless elegance that modern jewelry often lacks. Wearing one feels like connecting with the past while adding a unique charm to my outfit.
Another reason I find these brooches necessary is their versatility. Whether I’m dressing up for a special occasion or adding a subtle touch to everyday wear, a butterfly brooch instantly elevates my look. It’s a small detail that makes a big difference, showcasing my personal style with grace and sophistication.
Finally, antique butterfly brooch pins hold sentimental value. Many of mine have been passed down through generations, making them irreplaceable treasures. They remind me of loved ones and special moments, turning a simple accessory into something truly meaningful. For me, that’s why having these brooches is essential.
My Buying Guides on Antique Butterfly Brooches Pins
When I first started collecting antique butterfly brooch pins, I quickly realized there’s so much to consider to find pieces that truly resonate with me. If you’re like me and fascinated by these delicate and timeless accessories, here’s what I’ve learned to look out for.
Understanding the Appeal of Antique Butterfly Brooches
Butterfly brooches have always symbolized transformation, beauty, and freedom. Antique versions often carry a unique charm because of their craftsmanship and history. When I hold one, I feel connected to the era it came from, and that makes each piece special beyond its aesthetic appeal.
Materials and Craftsmanship
One of the first things I check is the material. Antique brooches can be made from gold, silver, platinum, or even costume jewelry metals. Genuine gemstones or enamel work often add to the piece’s value and beauty. I’ve found that hand-painted enamel details on butterfly wings make the brooch come alive. Also, look for hallmarks or maker’s marks that can authenticate and date the piece.
Condition and Wear
Because these are antique items, condition varies widely. I always inspect pins carefully for any damage like missing stones, bent pins, or worn metal. A little wear can add character, but structural damage can affect how wearable or display-worthy the brooch is. Sometimes, professional restoration is worth considering if the piece is otherwise exceptional.
Style and Era
Butterfly brooches have been popular across different periods — Victorian, Edwardian, Art Nouveau, and Art Deco, to name a few. I’ve found that identifying the era helps me understand the design style and typical materials used. For instance, Art Nouveau butterfly pins often feature flowing lines and naturalistic forms, while Art Deco pieces might have geometric shapes and bold colors.
Size and Wearability
I consider how I want to wear the brooch. Some antique butterfly pins are dainty and perfect for delicate outfits, while others are larger statement pieces. Knowing the size beforehand helps me decide if it fits my collection or wardrobe needs.
Authenticity and Provenance
When buying antique jewelry, I always ask for provenance if available. Knowing where the piece came from or its previous owners adds to its story and value. I also recommend buying from reputable dealers or auction houses to avoid reproductions or fakes.
Price and Budget
Prices for antique butterfly brooches can vary dramatically based on rarity, materials, and condition. I set a budget but remain flexible if I find a piece that truly speaks to me. Sometimes investing a bit more pays off in owning a timeless treasure.
Where to Buy Antique Butterfly Brooch Pins
I’ve found great pieces at antique shops, vintage jewelry fairs, online auction sites, and specialty dealers. Each has pros and cons — local shops let me inspect items in person, while online platforms offer a wider selection but require careful vetting.
Final Thoughts
Collecting antique butterfly brooch pins has been a rewarding journey for me. By paying close attention to craftsmanship, condition, style, and authenticity, I’ve built a collection that feels both beautiful and meaningful. I hope these tips help you find your own perfect butterfly brooch to cherish.
Author Profile
-
Judith Dunham is a lifelong lover of thoughtful living and intentional shopping. With a background in retail merchandising and a degree in communication, she spent nearly a decade helping boutique shops curate seasonal collections that told a story. Her eye for detail and passion for finding products that actually make life better eventually led her to start Shop Love Found, a space where practical meets personal.
Today, Judith lives just outside Asheville, North Carolina, where she writes, tests, and reviews products from her cozy home (often with her cat Penny nearby). Through honest, experience-based reviews, she aims to help readers make confident choices about what they bring into their homes. Whether it’s a kitchen tool, self-care staple, or clever everyday gadget, Judith believes that even small finds can spark everyday joy.
Latest entries
- July 31, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Ultimate Remote Controlled Excavator Toy: Here’s What I Discovered!
- July 31, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Acrylic Toilet Paper Holder: Here’s Why It’s a Game Changer for My Bathroom
- July 31, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested a 2.5 Inch Exhaust Kit: My Experience and Results
- July 31, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Best El Camino Car Cover: My Ultimate Protection Experience!